Paid to breastfeed?

What’s this? Me getting involved in current affairs and debate?! Regular readers will know this isn’t really my style. I’m much more likely to be found writing about my children’s dislike of carrots.

I’m the kind of person who doesn’t have strong opinions. I can usually see both sides to an argument and I hate conflict. And if I do have strong opinions, I tend to keep them to myself for fear of offending and upsetting others. But I do have quite strong opinions on breastfeeding.

People who know me see me as the breastfeeding police, as well as someone to turn to for advice. I spent three and a half years of my life breastfeeding, so I should have some half decent experience to share. If people ask for it. I won’t force my advice and opinions down their throats.

My view on breastfeeding is that everyone should be able to breastfeed. IF THAT IS WHAT THEY WANT TO DO. Yes, it’s best for the child, yes it’s usually better for the mum too, yes it’s cheaper and more convenient. But mums should still have the choice.

What about those who can’t breastfeed? My belief is that nearly everyone can. They just need the right support. For some people they will need that support for longer.

It’s not easy, nobody claims it is. Some women choose not to persist, others soldier on. Most will get there in the end.

I struggled to feed my eldest. He was three days old before he’d swallowed a single mouthful of milk. I knew this in my heart, but the midwives in hospital wouldn’t listen to me. What did I know? A first time mum? Well it turns out I knew my own body and my own baby better than they did.

So I was discharged from hospital, my son lost over a pound of his rather petite 7lb and then fell asleep for a really long time. Only then did I get the support I needed. My midwife came out to me late at night and spent hours with us. She helped me express (which I hated, but needs must) and, yes, we had to give him a little bit of formula. But with her support and my persistence, we made it. My son breastfed for 10 months.

Does everyone get that kind of support? I suspect not. But it would be brilliant if they could.

And so to today’s news. Payment in vouchers for women to breastfeed for six months. Good or bad?

Right now I don’t know enough about the scheme to be sure one way or another. I do know it’s a pilot in some fairly deprived areas of the country. Areas where, no doubt, breastfeeding rates are very low. I do know that breastfeeding has long term health benefits for a child – in boosting immunity, helping maintain a healthy weight and even preventing ear infections for up to seven years. Between my three kids, they’ve had just two ear infections in their entire lives. Coincidence? Probably not.

I don’t know how they will manage this scheme – do they make the payment beforehand and then trust the woman to see her six months through? Or do they spy on her? Maybe they make the payment after the six months is over? Is it for exclusive breastfeeding or for simply not giving up? I went back to work when all of mine were 6 months old, so had no choice but to introduce bottles from 5 months. But I didn’t give up though!

Presumably the costs of paying out £200 per woman have been weighed up against the cost of doctor’s visits, prescriptions and long-term health prospects? Two hundred pounds can be swallowed up VERY quickly in NHS services for a child.

So is incentivising women to breastfeed a good idea or a bad one? In my married, middle class world where breastfeeding is the norm, it might seem like a bad one. But actually, if it can help change the culture and the health of children in areas where it isn’t the norm, maybe JUST MAYBE, it might be a good one.

Author: Sarah Mummy

Share This Post On

8 Comments

  1. Great post, I breastfed all three of mine, but my eldest I only managed it for 6 weeks but then went on to 14 months with my middle one and 3 years with my youngest (not my choice!).
    It should be up to the mother to choose and if all the facts and support are there then they can make an informed choice too. I am undecided whether this is a good idea to pay women to breastfeed as if they genuinely can’t, it will be putting new mothers who may need the extra money under even more stress, which as a new mum, you really don’t need any more.
    I will be interested to see what happens after the scheme.

    Post a Reply
  2. Good stuff from my official breastfeeding counsellor! I’d like to see more time spent on Dads too. Research shows that the partner’s view has a big impact. I know women who dint do it because their partner don’t like it, or want people to see their boobs. These things have a huge impact on women at their most vulnerable time. Personally not a fan of the shopping voucher bribery, breastfeeding isn’t about money, otherwise everyone would be doing it cos it saves you so much cash!

    Post a Reply
  3. Great post. I am with you on all of it apart from throwing the incentives at women – I just think it will be too open to abuse more than anything.
    I was determined to breastfeed and nothing would stop me. Like you I had initial problems initially, but with the right support and advice I made it! I really think that all women can breastfeed and many give up far too soon. It takes at least 6 weeks for everything to settle into a routine and babies need to establish a routine and feeding them helps stimulate milk supply and your bodies regulate to each other. Day two with Sebastian I remember thinking he was attached to me all day, but the midwife putting it succinctly – he was working his little socks off trying to stimulate my milk supply.

    Post a Reply
  4. Thanks very much, ladies! I didn’t say in my post, but breastfeeding came very easily with my other two and they both fed for longer. I also had the confidence to go out and feed in public, which I didn’t have with my eldest.
    It will be interesting to see the results of this pilot, Kizzy. Although I guess long-term results would take a long time to come through.
    Good point about the dads, Uley Girl, which I hadn’t considered. My husband was very good at helping me to breastfeed in the early days, but I don’t suppose they all are.
    Kara – you really are an expert on this! You’re right about the six weeks – by six weeks things are usually settled and that’s when it generally gets easier. It seems a long time at the time, but looking back it’s just a drop in the ocean. Bless Sebastian feeding all day!

    Post a Reply

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Paid to breastfeed? | LAB - […] Read the rest of the post at it’s original source by clicking here. […]

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: